Please vote for the “Best Idea Since Sliced Bread”
A good friend of mine just told me that her idea had been chosen as one of 21 finalists out of 22,000 submissions in the national “Best Idea Since Sliced Bread” contest – which challenged people to submit ideas on how to improve the US economy. After two rounds of Internet voting, the judges will pick the winner from the top three. Best idea wins $100,000 but what’s really fantastic is a panel of experts and policy makers will work to turn the winning idea into law.
It’s not just because she is my friend, but also because I kind of like the idea that I wanted to alert you to this one and ask you to go vote for the idea if you like it as well. Her idea is called “ProdiMae Efficient Access to Capital” and involves a method where small business owners get similar level of straightforward and efficient access to capital that homeowners get to mortgages. You can cast your vote here.
[Technorati Tags: best idea since sliced bread economy entrepreneurship]
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
February 2nd, 2006 at 1:04 pm
The winning idea and two runners up in the SinceSliced Bread contest sponsored by the Service Employees International Union (ironically this contest was open only to U.S. citizens) were announced on February 1, 2006; see the SinceSliced Bread website:
http://www.sinceslicedbread.com
This idea, like the other 20 “finalist” ideas displayed at the SSB site, fails to comply with the contest rules (also available at the SSB site, in their third or fourth version) requiring ideas submitted to be original. The contest sponsor, SEIU, has induced thousands of people to hand over their intellectual property on the premise that they had a chance to win $100,000 or $50,000 on the merits of their ideas–not on their correspondence with the previously well-publicized political agenda of SEIU, but the latter criterion was the actual principle of selection. All the “finalist” ideas can be found at the SinceSlicedBread website.
While there are many actually original and creative ideas in the ideas database of over 22,000 ideas, the selected ideas have all been published in public policy discussions over the past few decades and some of them even duplicate legislation which has been introduced in Congress.
Additionally, the contest rules established priority of submission as the tie-breaking criterion in the event of multiple submissions of the same or substantially similar ideas. Many of the ideas in the 21 “finalists” list have been shown to have been duplicated by lowered-numbered (and therefore earlier) submissions.
At least one lawsuit has been filed against SEIU, and several complaints have been lodged with the attorneys general of the states of residence of participants.
SEIU has failed to admit to any responsiblity for having compromised the contest and ripped off participants who actually followed the rules.
Hundreds of pages of complaints about this situation have been posted to the SinceSlicedBread blog–which was abruptly removed from their site a few hours before the winners were announced.
The blog includes a great deal of evidence for SEIU’s failure to follow its own rules and for the nonoriginality of the selected ideas. I have backed up all the blog threads begun since the “finalists” were announced and I can make these documents available on request.
Sincerely,
Kevin Langdon
P.O. Box 795
Berkeley, CA 94701
(510) 524-0345
kevin.langdon@polymath-systems.com
http://www.polymath-systems.com